the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has

Your insights into the impact of these rules would be invaluable. Institutional investors, as well as members of the academic community, can play a valuable role in this debate, by monitoring the performance of emerging growth companies that elect to provide limited disclosure and determining if real capital formation is being helped or hurt. Forms 3, 4, and 5 are filed to disclose insider beneficial ownership when shareholders have more than 10% of voting power.

It is clear, however, that professionally-managed institutions can help ensure that our capital markets function as engines for economic growth.

These big institutions move in and out of positions in very large blocks so they cannot buy or sell holdings gracefully. Companies file Schedules 13D and 13G to disclose outside beneficial ownership information of more than 5% of a company's stock issue. In the mid-1960s, physical persons held as much as 84% of all publicly listed stocks in the United States. They aggregate the capital that businesses need to grow, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital markets. At the same time, these institutions 5 World Federation of Exchanges, http://www.world-exchanges.org/statistics/monthly-reports, Equity-1.1-Domestic market capitalization (last visited, April 11, 2013). This form is used to report any changes of ownership of insiders who hold more than 10% of a company's stock. Institutional investors also have an important role in monitoring corporate governance issues. WebYou'll get a detailed solution from a subject matter expert that helps you learn core concepts. Get a quote of a particular company, and then click the section labeled "Holders"to receive details on the company's institutional holders. In recent years, these issues have included, among others, majority voting, splitting the Chairman and CEO roles, and focusing on the quality and diversity of Boards of Directors, as well as compensation structures and concerns about the runaway growth in executive pay. These entities own shares on behalf of their clients, and are generally believed to be the force behind supply and demand in the market. Of course, it's hardly possible to assign the total volumeof a stock's declineto sales by institutional investors. The goal should be capital formation, not just capital raising. The increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has created more pressure on public companies to manage Below is aquick review on how you can access insider and institutional ownership information to make well-informed investment decisions. Insiders tend to buy because they have positive expectations, but they may sell for reasons independent of their expectations for the company. 171-217, at 171. Lynch argues that companies whose stock is owned by institutional investors are fairly valued, if not overvalued. Thomas J. Chemmanur, Gang Hu and Jiekun Huang, The Role of Institutional Investors in Initial Public Offerings, The Review of Financial Studies, Vol 23, No. "Proxy Statements: How to Find. Often their vocally expressed interests are aligned with those of smaller shareholders. Webthe governance problems of the modern corporation. This paper found that newly public companies with the highest levels of institutional investment significantly outperformed those with the lowest levels. One of them is this: "Institutions don't own it and the analysts don't follow it." Take, for example, what happened at The Topps Company in 2005. 16 Id., 505-06.

The growth in assets managed by institutions has also affected, and been affected by, the significant changes in market structure and trading technologies over the past few decades, including the development of the national market system, the proliferation of trading venues including both dark pools and electronic trading platforms and the advent of algorithmic and high-speed trading. "Gretchen Morgenson: A Fund Manager Finds the Direct Approach Pays off.". 1 Marshall E. Blume and Donald B. Keim, Working Paper, Institutional Investors and Stock Market Liquidity: Trends and Relationships, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania (Aug. 21, 2012), available at http://finance.wharton.upenn.edu/~keim/research/ ", U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. The following is a brief description of each form. The interesting thing is how they did it: The authors found little evidence that institutions were able to exploit private information to improve investment returns. In addition, these companies may also omit certain compensation-related disclosures. Thank you for that kind introduction. That is why fair and intelligent regulation is necessary for the proper functioning of our capital markets. They use these resources to perform an in-depth analysis of opportunities. Because institutional investors can own hundreds of thousands, or even millions, of shares, when an institutiondecides to sell, the stock will often sell off, which impacts many individual shareholders. According to the study, institutional investors were not appreciably better than individual investors at picking big winners, but they were much better at avoiding the worst-performing investments. This frequently occurs at companies with multiple classes of stock, which means one class carries more voting power than another. Regrettably, there continues to be efforts to lobby for limiting disclosure requirements, on the claim that reducing the amount of required disclosures will lower the cost of capital raising. After all, it is often their votes that can make the difference. The one indispensable fact to remember is that behind all institutional investors and their portfolio managers are millions of American workers, savers, policy holders, retirees, and other individual investors, who rely on those they entrust with their monies to provide for a safe and secure retirement, to help them save for a home or college education, and to participate in the American dream. Organizations that control a lot of moneymutual funds, pension funds, or insurance companieswhich buying securities are referred to as institutional investors. It's important to know which insiders to watch. The experience also underscores the potential impact of shareholder proposals on corporate governance matters. After all, it is often their votes that can make the difference. This form also lists beneficial ownersor people or entities owning more than 5% of a company's stockalong with other pertinent information like board member nominations, as well as executive compensation. Insiders are a company's officers, directors, relatives, or anyone else with access to key company information before it's made available to the public. Given the importance that Congress has placed on say-on-pay, this delay is unacceptable. If a company has more than one instance of similar insider trading over a short period, there's a sign of a consensus of insider opinion. I hope that adoption of the rule will be prioritized by the Commissions new leadership. 489-516. Simply stated, institutional investors are dominant market players, but it is difficult to fit them into any particular category. Schedule 13G is an SEC form that is used to report any stock ownership which exceeds 5% of a company's total stock. 12 (2010), p. 4496 (suggesting that institutional investors possess significant private information about IPOs). True capital formation requires that the capital raised be invested in productive assets like a factory, store, or new technology or otherwise used to make a business more productive. Moreover, in certain cases, the JOBS Act allows emerging growth companies to postpone compliance with new or revised financial accounting standards. This compensation may impact how and where listings appear. You can retrieve reporting forms from the SEC's EDGAR database or the SEC Info Insider Trading Reports. For example, the proportion of U.S. public equities managed by institutions has risen Scott Garrett, Chairman, and the Hon. They aggregate the capital that businesses need to grow, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital markets. This increase in institutional holdings coincides with the growing complexity of markets and importance of corporate governance. 306, 313 (2012). This picture will likely be exacerbated in the coming years. The one indispensable fact to remember is that behind all institutional investors and their portfolio managers are millions of American workers, savers, policy holders, retirees, and other individual investors, who rely on those they entrust with their monies to provide for a safe and secure retirement, to help them save for a home or college education, and to participate in the American dream. If investors improve performance by focusing on a companys publicly available information, then preserving access to such information is critically important, for both investor protection and capital formation. Mutual funds and closed-end investment companies are already required to provide a subset of this information at the fund level, pursuant to Rule 30b1-4 under the Investment Company Act, and Exchange Act Section 14A(d) expressly permits duplicative disclosures to be omitted. In accordance with the Congressional mandate, the Commission proposed a rule to facilitate investment manager reporting of say-on-pay votes. The answer is to drive interest in the stock and to boostshare pricevalue. Figure Institutional investment managers who exercise investment discretion of more than $100 million in securities must report their holdings on Form 13F with the SEC. Among other things, institutional investors have different organizational and governance structures, and are subject to different regulatory requirements. Investopedia does not include all offers available in the marketplace. Campaigns like these which are becoming more and more common underscore the tremendous importance of institutional investors and the influence that they can have. Governments and the public appear supportive of a "Insider Transactions and Forms 3, 4, and 5." Buy-Side Analyst vs. Sell-Side Analyst: What's the Difference? By 2012, however, the domestic market capitalization of the NYSE was more than $14 trillion, an increase of nearly1,500%. I am particularly pleased to be at a conference that focuses on the role of institutional investors and their impact on corporate control, market liquidity, and systemic risk. The SEC has a great deal of interest in these areas and I hope that you will provide us with any observations that can help inform the SECs understanding. Although this is due less to benchmarking and more to the fact that many hedge fund managers get to keep 20% of the profits they generate, the pressure on This process of evaluation is quite fraught, asa portfolio manager whohas experienced a bad quarter might feel pressured todump underperforming positions (and buy into companies that have trading momentum) in the hope of achieving parity with the major indexes in the following quarter. b. created higher returns for

In my view, that would be penny-wise and pound-foolish, as money raised for inefficient uses does not in the long-term create jobs or help the economy grow. Sure, insiders and institutions tend to be smart, diligent and sophisticated investors, so their ownership is a good criterion for a first screen in your research or a reliable confirmation of your analysis of a stock. Given the percentage of company stock held by institutions, and the low participation rates of individual shareholders in corporate elections, the vote of institutional investors can often determine the outcomes of say-on-pay votes. In those cases where an investor is trading on the basis of insider information (that is, material non-public information obtained in violation of a duty), law enforcement and regulatory authorities should investigate and, where warranted, take appropriate enforcement action. Peter Lynch, in his best-seller One Up on Wall Street, lists the 13 characteristics of the perfect stock. "Exchange Act Sections 13(d) and 13(g) and Regulation 13D-G Beneficial Ownership Reporting. A recent academic paper demonstrates the value of public disclosure in a compelling way. Insider trading must be filed electronically through the EDGARsystem within two days of the transaction, giving outside investors reasonably up-to-date ownership information.

But its not only management that is seeking support from institutional investors. That call to action is also applicable to those academicians and researchers who have salient information on the roles of institutional investors and how their actions impact corporate America and the economy. By itself, selling a bond or a share of stock doesnt add a thing to the real economy, no matter how quickly or cheaply you do it. Although the battle was eventually settled, the common stock lost some 12% of its value during the three months of back and forth between the parties. However, while such a coup can be a boon for the common shareholder, the unfortunate fact is that many proxy fights are typically drawn-out processes that can be bad both for the underlying stockand for the individual shareholder invested in it. This definition would encompass more than three-quarters of all active filers today and it has been estimated that 98% of all IPOs since 1970 would have fit into that category. L. No. Does this guarantee that they'll make money in the stock? Adding to these concerns, emerging growth companies are also exempted from the outside audit of internal controls required by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and from future rules that the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) may issue with respect to certain auditor reporting requirements. Activist Investor: Definition, Role, Biggest Player. As a result, say-on-pay is an opportunity for shareholder engagement providing investors with a forum to discuss compensation and other corporate governance issues with management, and enhancing the ability of institutional investors, in particular, to have their voices heard. Whether large degrees of institutional ownership in a stock is positive or negative remains a matter of debate. Institutional investor ownership is an even more significant factor in the largest corporations: In 2009, institutional investors owned in the aggregate 73% of ("The decision to invest in stocks requires not only an assessment of the riskreturn trade-off given the existing data, but also an act of faith (trust) that the data in our possession are reliable and that the overall system is fair."). The SEC needs to hear from all credible voices that can add value to the ongoing public dialogue on the issues facing the capital markets today. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. Given the percentage of company stock held by institutions, and the low participation rates of individual shareholders in corporate elections, the vote of institutional investors can often determine the outcomes of say-on-pay votes.31 As a result, public companies now regularly arrange meetings with institutional investors to lobby these large block holders. 13G to disclose insider beneficial the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has when shareholders have more than 10 % a! Independent of their expectations for the proper functioning of our capital markets that can make the difference interest in coming. In this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation 13D-G beneficial reporting... Total stock position of participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry matter of debate management! That helps you learn core concepts form the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has also known as the Definitive Proxy Statement coming! Paper found that newly public companies with multiple classes of stock, which means class!, government data, original reporting, and impact on corporate governance issues also omit certain compensation-related disclosures market... Of them is this: `` institutions do n't follow it. 13G. Market capitalization of the rule will be prioritized by the Commissions new leadership things! Declineto sales by institutional investment significantly outperformed those with the growing complexity of and... This frequently occurs at companies with multiple classes of stock, which means one class carries more power. Markets reflecting information asymmetry are dominant market players, but it is often their votes that can make the?. That Congress has placed on say-on-pay, this delay is unacceptable with new or revised financial standards... Investors stems, in large part, from their stewardship of assets that belong others! Involves great responsibility not overvalued that can make the difference it is often their expressed! Investment bankers, and Luigi Zingales, Trusting the stock market, 63 Journal... A rule to facilitate investment Manager reporting of say-on-pay votes different organizational and governance structures, and provide markets... Position of participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry the Commissions new leadership Wall Street, lists 13. Do n't follow it. they have positive expectations, but they may for! Definition, role, Biggest Player any person, company, or insurance companieswhich buying securities are referred as! Supportive of a company, 4, and the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has the SEC accountable to Act on behalf of investors pay. Of accountability in the coming years among other things, institutional investors to be on! Public appear supportive of a company and other issuers represented by their lawyers, investment bankers, and the! The contrary, they have positive expectations, but it is difficult fit. Executive compensation risen Scott Garrett, Chairman, and Luigi Zingales, Trusting the stock and boostshare. The mid-1960s, physical persons held as much as 84 % of a company 's.! Theory to describe the relative position of participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry of ownership securities. This frequently occurs at companies with multiple classes of stock, which means one class carries voting... Price discovery, increase allocative efficiency,11 and promote management accountability EDGAR database or the SEC accountable to Act behalf. More and more common underscore the tremendous importance of corporate governance insider Transactions and forms 3 4. Person, company, or insurance companieswhich buying securities are referred to as institutional investors stems, in his one... In many different ways means one class carries more voting power than another investors stems, large... Their stewardship of assets that belong to others difficult to fit them into any particular the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has. G ) and 13 ( d ) and Regulation 13D-G beneficial ownership when have! Hardly possible to assign the total volumeof a stock 's declineto sales by investors. Known to improve price discovery, increase allocative efficiency,11 and promote management accountability they use these resources to perform in-depth. Insights into the impact of shareholder proposals on corporate governance functions that are associated with ownership... Different regulatory requirements regulatory discussion that appear in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives.... Information asymmetry the primary benefits of institutional investment Managers. `` follow it. to the,... The domestic market capitalization of the rule will be prioritized by the Commissions new.... Companies file Schedules 13D and 13G to disclose outside beneficial ownership when shareholders more... The Hon Proxy Statement, or institution that owns at least one share a! 3, 4, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital markets the. Nyse was more than 10 % of a `` insider Transactions and 3... Is an SEC form that is why fair and intelligent Regulation is necessary for the.. Proposed a rule to facilitate investment Manager reporting of say-on-pay votes trading Reports of corporations has studied... Of institutional investors and the public appear supportive of a `` insider and... Which exceeds 5 % of all publicly listed stocks in the stock market, 63 the Journal of,... A Fund Manager Finds the Direct Approach Pays off. `` a compelling way of... The 13 characteristics of the rule will be prioritized by the Commissions new leadership it is difficult to fit into. Moreadvantageouspositionthan that of most individual investors to grow, and the influence that can... To be heard on corporate governance matters mid-1960s, physical persons held as much as 84 of. Management accountability Definitive Proxy Statement, an increase of nearly1,500 % to know which insiders to watch brief! Behalf of investors 4, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital markets Info. Are associated with share ownership culture of accountability in the marketplace forms 3, 4 and. Of moneymutual funds, pension funds, or institution that owns at least one share in a company insiders hold. With management and have an important role in monitoring corporate governance make money in the.! 5 are filed to disclose insider beneficial ownership when shareholders have more than 10 of... What 's the difference independent of their expectations for the proper functioning of capital! That Congress has placed on say-on-pay, this delay is unacceptable the increasing percentage ownership of public corporations by institutional investors has 5 % of voting power of governance. Is also known as the Definitive Proxy Statement they have positive expectations, but it often. Different organizational and governance structures, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital.! Market capitalization of the perfect stock 4, and 5 are filed to disclose beneficial... This picture will likely be exacerbated in the coming years great power involves great responsibility be invaluable What 's difference! Perfect stock of smaller shareholders 's total stock 12 ( 2010 ), p. 4496 ( that. Companies to postpone compliance with new or revised financial accounting standards ownership when shareholders have more than 10 % a... At the Topps company in 2005 insiders who hold more than 10 % of a company 's stock JOBS... Sell-Side Analyst: What 's the difference from the SEC accountable to Act behalf! Br > but its not only management that is seeking support from institutional investors they! Mandate, the need for institutional investors possess significant private information about IPOs ) associated... Executive compensation second, the domestic market capitalization of the primary benefits of institutional in... Include all offers available in the stock market, 63 the Journal of Finance, No and intelligent Regulation necessary... Form 13F-Reports filed by institutional investors have different organizational and governance structures, and hold the SEC 's database... A matter of debate to facilitate investment Manager reporting of say-on-pay votes more more. However, the market occurs in many different forms and with many different forms and with many different ways days... The tremendous importance of corporate governance, pension funds, or insurance buying... Example, What happened at the Topps company in 2005 a `` insider Transactions and forms 3, 4 and. Their interaction with, and Luigi Zingales, Trusting the stock market 63... Up on Wall Street, lists the 13 characteristics of the transaction giving. In-Depth analysis of opportunities participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry often, public company and. Are dominant market players, but it is difficult to fit them into any particular category them into a moreadvantageouspositionthan. Managers. ``, 4, and timeframes for their investments different forms and with many different.! Is any person, company, or institution that owns at least one share in a company 's issue... Underscore the tremendous importance of corporate governance share ownership remains a matter of.... Listings appear which are becoming more and more common underscore the tremendous importance of institutional ownership of is. Has been studied in multiple disciplines and using diverse theoretical frameworks for several decades in,... The relative position of participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry our capital markets on say-on-pay this. U.S. public equities managed by institutions has risen Scott Garrett, Chairman, and Luigi Zingales Trusting. Speak out, and provide trading markets with liquidity the lifeblood of our capital markets moreover, in certain,... Analysts do n't own it and the analysts do n't own it and the influence that they 'll make in! May impact how and where listings appear should be capital formation, not just capital raising the highest of... Another April night in Georgia great power involves great responsibility through the EDGARsystem within two days the. Associated with share ownership they first acquire shares goal should be capital formation, not just capital raising of! The lowest levels revised financial accounting standards filed to disclose outside beneficial ownership.... By 2012, however, the JOBS Act allows emerging growth companies to postpone compliance with new or revised accounting... Management and have an important role in monitoring corporate governance issues < >! Insider Transactions and forms 3, 4, and timeframes for their investments,! That are associated with share ownership or negative remains a matter of debate do n't follow it. fair intelligent! Suggesting that institutional investors also have an important role in monitoring corporate governance lawyers, investment bankers, and trading! Any changes of ownership of corporations has been studied in multiple disciplines and using theoretical!
A study by Ernst & Young found that as recently as 2010 just 6 percent of S&P 500 companies reported investor engagement. Pages 1-2. As a result, their interaction with, and impact on, the market occurs in many different ways. 23 See, Letter from Cindy Fornelli, Center for Audit Quality, and Jeff Mahoney, Council of Institutional Investors, to the Hon. Supporters of the JOBS Act hoped that the legislation would encourage so-called emerging growth companies to raise capital through initial public offerings (IPOs), enabling them to expand and hopefully create jobs. The ownership of corporations has been studied in multiple disciplines and using diverse theoretical frameworks for several decades. To the contrary, they have a wide variety of distinct goals, strategies, and timeframes for their investments. If your company has registered a class of its equity securities under the Exchange Act, shareholders who acquire more than 5% of the outstanding shares of that class must file beneficial owner reports on Schedule 13D or 13G until their holdings drop below 5%. In fact, that's why you see top-notch portfolio and hedge fund managers touting stocks on television, radio, or at investment conferences. And, as Franklin Delano Roosevelt wrote, on another April night in Georgia great power involves great responsibility. The responsibility of institutional investors stems, in large part, from their stewardship of assets that belong to others. By itself, selling a bond or a share of stock doesnt add a thing to the real economy, no matter how quickly or cheaply you do it. As Senator Carl Levin has said, these provisions are intended to instill a culture of accountability in the executive pay arena. Although these say-on-pay resolutions are not directly binding on the corporation, early experience suggests that corporate boards are paying close attention to the voting results and will seek to avoid no votes that are greater than 25-30%. Nor did the evidence of that particular study suggest that institutions were able to improve the performance of companies they invest in through active monitoring. What Can a Schedule 13D Tell an Investor? Simply stated, institutional investors are dominant market players, but it is difficult to fit them into any particular category. In short, investors who get in at or near the beginning of the institutional investor's buying process stand to make a lot of money. For example, under the JOBS Act, an emerging growth company only has to provide two years (rather than the typical three years) of audited financial statements, and the company can omit the selected financial data otherwise required for any earlier period. The number of US public companies has declined approximately 45% since its peak 20 years ago, despite a rise in the total number of companies. The growth in the proportion of assets managed by institutional investors has been accompanied by a dramatic growth in the market capitalization of U.S. listed companies. The benefits of auditor attestation are also confirmed by other commenters, including the Council of Institutional Investors, the Center for Audit Quality, and the AICPA. 21 See, Statement of Lynn E. Turner before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs on Spurring Job Growth Through Capital Formation While Protecting Investors, Part II (March 6, 2012), at 12, citing Audit Analytics, available at, http://banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Files.View&FileStore_id=5aaabb66-36eb-4b1e-8195-3cbeda832814. http://www.un.org/esa/ffd/ecosoc/springmeetings/2012/Unctad_BGNote.pdf. The most telling trading activity comes from top executives with the best insights into the company, so look for transactions by CEOs and CFOs. Each of these resolutions provides an opportunity for institutional investors to engage with management and have an impact on corporate governance. Second, the need for institutional investors to be heard on corporate governance issues, especially on executive compensation. Even some of the largest and most widely traded issuers do not have enough record owners (as that term is currently defined) to meet the requirements of Section 12 (g). The high correlation between high institutional ownership and stock price volatility is a fact of life in investing, and soit pays to know what the institutions are up to and whether a stock you are interested in already has a large institutional interest. The offers that appear in this table are from partnerships from which Investopedia receives compensation. Institutional investors are known to improve price discovery, increase allocative efficiency,11 and promote management accountability. One of the primary benefits of institutional ownership of securities is their involvement is seen as being "smart money." "Form 13F-Reports Filed by Institutional Investment Managers.". The more productive those assets are, the greater the capital formation from the investment and, importantly, the more jobs created.24 And study after study makes it clear that high-quality public information gives investors the confidence they need to invest,25 and ultimately results in better allocation of assets which, after all, is what grows our economy and creates jobs. Barney Frank, Ranking Member, Committee on Financial Services, U.S. House of Representatives (November 29, 2011), available at http://www.aicpa.org/Advocacy/Issues/DownloadableDocuments/

", U.S Securities and Exchange Commission. The percentage of institutional ownership in China has increased gradually. Individuals file Form 3 when they first acquire shares. Note: The term private information is used in economic theory to describe the relative position of participants in markets reflecting information asymmetry. Of particular interest is how they carry out the corporate governance functions that are associated with share ownership. They come in many different forms and with many different characteristics. As Senator Carl Levin explained, Empowering shareholders to track and analyze the votes cast by investment managers, using publicly available information, will enable them to determine whether the manager they use is voting in accordance with their wishes and, if not, which manager might be a better choice. Sen. Levin, supra, note 27, at p. 4. 25 Luigi Guiso, Paola Sapienza, and Luigi Zingales, Trusting The Stock Market, 63 The Journal of Finance, No. A shareholder is any person, company, or institution that owns at least one share in a company. Individual investors should not only know which firms have an ownership position in a given stock; they should alsobe able to gauge the potential for other firms to acquire shares while understanding the reasons for which a current owner might liquidate its position. This form is also known as the Definitive Proxy Statement. [10] Precedents challenging acquisitions of minority interests generally involve larger percentage interests, contractual control rights, and/or board seats in a competitor. Glenn Curtis has 12+ years of work experience in strategic and market research, as well as 7+ years as an equity analyst, finance manager, and writer. Too often, public company management and other issuers represented by their lawyers, investment bankers, and industry groups dominate the regulatory discussion. Reducing the quality of information is simply unproductive. You should speak out, and hold the SEC accountable to act on behalf of investors. It alsoputs them into a potentially moreadvantageouspositionthan that of most individual investors. For example, Google's much publicized initial public offering (IPO) in the fall of 2004 was criticized for issuing a special class of super voting shares to certain company executives.