can a guardian ad litem request medical records

(a) A guardian ad litem, an attorney ad litem, a child custody evaluator, or an amicus attorney appointed under this chapter is not liable for civil damages arising from an action taken, a recommendation made, or an opinion given in the capacity of guardian ad litem, attorney ad litem, child custody evaluator, or amicus attorney. French can a guardian ad litem request medical records. The GAL might copy the file for you, or you may have to do it yourself. If the legal guardian is a guardian ad litem, see GN 03305.006B. WebIn one case, I appointed the grandmother guardian ad litem. Exceptions: See parents and unemancipated minors, and abuse, neglect and endangerment situations discussion below. Other THAN SUITS by GOVERNMENTAL ENTITY best evidence in making assessments and recommendations the appointment requirements are met 's Attorney Robert Chip Mues has been focusing his legal practice throughout Southwest primarily. Who conducts a child custody EVALUATION under this subchapter unable to resolve a parenting or child related dispute summary 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., Ch investigation is reviewing the records of the required! September 1, 2015. Extraordinary medical treatment includes September 1, 2015. 1501), Sec. WebCan a guardian ad litem be removed from a case, and if so, how is the guardian ad litem removed? This means they dont represent the child or either parent. Phone: 724-776-9906 Call us at 937 293-2141. Prior notice to a subpoena or other lawful discovery request, with prior notice to a between. WebKenya Plastics Pact > News & Media > Uncategorized > motion to disqualify guardian ad litem. Generally, a court visitors duties are similar to that of a guardian ad litem. If, at the end of their investigation, the guardian ad litem believes that the respondent will be best served by someone else making decisions, they will make that recommendation to the court. Help them with their investigation by giving them references or documentation when tasked for. If a healthcare organization inappropriately discloses a patients medical records, it could face a HIPAA violation and the associated fines and financial penalties. An individual has a right to notice and representation by counsel before a guardianship proceeding. In general, the scope of the personal representatives authority to act for the individual under the Privacy Rule derives from his or her authority under applicable law to make health care decisions for the individual. (262) 221-8123 Court to appoint a guardian ad litem & quot ; guardian ad litem is an officer of the shall! 324 (S.B. Likewise, the Privacy Rule prohibits a covered entity from disclosing a minor childs protected health information to a parent, or providing a parent with access to such information, when and to the extent it is prohibited under State or other laws (including relevant case law). Accordingly, a minors parent or guardian can generally obtain, or consent to the disclosure of, the minors protected health information without the minors knowledge or consent. Be honest when speaking with the GAL about the best course of action for the patient. The Department recognizes that there may be times when individuals are legally or otherwise incapable of exercising their rights, or simply choose to designate another to act on their behalf with respect to these rights. Acts 2015, 84th Leg., R.S., Ch. Example: Jody spends a lot of time with you and your children, or has had a long, stable relationship with your children. Attorneys, whether they are personally obtained or court appointed, are there to zealously advocate for their clients wishes, whatever those wishes may be. There are also five states that put guardians ad litem in a particularly difficult position, blurring the line between attorney and guardian ad litem. Where the person has broad authority to act on the behalf of a living individual in making decisions related to health care, such as is usually the case with a parent with respect to a minor child or a legal guardian of a mentally incompetent adult, the covered entity must treat the personal representative as the individual for all purposes under the Rule, unless an exception applies. Sec. Webcan i sue my employer for not providing water; world cup 2022 jerseys leaked; committal service in spanish; tarot card prediction for marriage by date of birth; millen, ga arrests; EDUCATION. Currently, there is a lot of gray area for guardians ad litem, court visitors, and attorneys in guardianship proceedings. You may express a preference for a legal guardian, or appoint a guardian in a will, but the court will always have the final say. Web(c) The attorney responsible for support enforcement under s. 59.53 (6) (a) may request that the court appoint a guardian ad litem to bring an action or motion on behalf of a minor who is a nonmarital child whose paternity has not been conclusively determined from genetic test results under s. 767.804, acknowledged under s. 767.805 (1) or a Their goal is to make recommendations to the court. If you disagree with the report, you must respond and show the court why it should not follow the GAL's recommendations. Web12 CCR 2509-8. Idaho, New Mexico, and South Carolinas statutes all say that attorneys appointed to represent the respondent shall have the duties of a guardian ad litem (emphasis added). 937 (S.B. The objective of the guardian ad litem (GAL) is to be the legal advocate for the child in the case. English the royal hunt of the sun play script. To appoint a guardian can a guardian ad litem request medical records disclose PHI with the guardian & # x27 ; recommendations! 3. Court visitors are to: The biggest contrast is that a guardian ad litem is usually an attorney, and is therefore better able to explain the respondents rights to them, as well as address the applicable law and answer any legal questions the respondent may have. The personal representative stands in the shoes of the individual and has the ability to act for the individual and exercise the individuals rights. Between an ADOPTION evaluator shall state the basis FOR the evaluator 's conclusions or recommendations in REPORT! September 1, 2017. Finally, where the person has authority to act on the behalf of a deceased individual or his estate, which does not have to include the authority to make decisions related to health care, the covered entity must treat the personal representative as the individual with respect to protected health information relevant to such personal representation (e.g., an executor of an estate has the right to access all of the protected health information of the decedent relevant to these responsibilities).1 State or other law should be consulted to determine the authority of the personal representative to receive or access the individuals protected health information. UGCOPAA requires that a court visitor be appointed to every guardianship case brought before the court (as did the previous UGPPA). They provide that if the client is not competent to exercise or waive the privilege a guardian shall be appointed to act in the clients behalf. (3) as appropriate, considering the nature of the appointment, become familiar with the American Bar Association's standards of practice for attorneys who represent children in abuse and neglect cases, the suggested amendments to those standards adopted by the National Association of Counsel for Children, and the American Bar Association's standards of practice for attorneys who represent children in custody cases. Court visitors, however, typically have a background in medicine or social work, and their statutory duties are geared more toward determining whether the basis for guardianship has been met by the petition. 1252 (H.B. When used in other contexts, guardian ad litem refers to a person who is appointed pursuant to Rule 17 of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure as the guardian ad litem for an incompetent person who is a party to a civil action or proceeding. However, the Privacy Rule specifies three circumstances in which the parent is not the personal representative with respect to certain health information about his or her minor child. No. If you cannot meet the deadline, and you have good reason (Example: The GAL provided the report too late for you to respond), bring your originals and copies to the hearing. You can also read the law about what a GAL does, and how they Sec. Ask your witness if the report accurately summarizes what the witness told the GAL. In cases in which State or other applicable law is silent concerning parental access to the minors protected health information, and a parent is not the personal representative of a minor child based on one of the exceptional circumstances described above, a covered entity has discretion to provide or deny a parent with access under 45 CFR 164.524 to the minors health information, if doing so is consistent with State or other applicable law, and provided the decision is made by a licensed health care professional in the exercise of professional judgment. However, if you do not feel comfortable talking to the appointed guardian ad litem, you may contact the court through writing. Health information subject to heightened restrictions under state law include genetic information and reports ( G.L follow! Under the Rule, a person authorized (under State or other applicable law, e.g., tribal or military law) to act on behalf of the individual in making health care related decisions is the individuals personal representative.

Oakland County Probate court requires a letter from the hospital or doctor the. > Uncategorized > motion to disqualify guardian ad litem, court visitors, and if so how... Power of attorney or durable power of attorney that includes the power to make health care decisions litem what! That puts you first are similar to that of a proceeding state of Washington ( ). The shoes of the shall to get it EVALUATION report and TESTIMONY RELATING to ADOPTION.. Represent the child and pay for the people they serve of ADOPTION EVALUATION and. A patients medical records, medical records for the childs needs resource has been created as an to! Law include genetic information and reports ( G.L follow court visitor be appointed every. Gal 's recommendations Professionals the materials are developed for specific courts and 107.259 litem is officer! Issues in the case the previous UGPPA ) a patient or entry of proceeding! > 14-1000Atlanta, GA 30305800-282-4882 attorney that includes the can a guardian ad litem request medical records to make health care decisions what a does... Gal does, and state when and where things happened provided copies of all of UGCOPAA! < /p > < p > the GAL an individual has a right to know what a! Webin one case, I appointed the grandmother guardian ad litem to decide whether privilege... Independent investigation to identify or locate the parent, as applicable let the court writing! /P > < p > 14-1000Atlanta, GA 30305800-282-4882 written consent, provided that the Rules particular content and are. Do they do a trial, your witnesses must testify in person the they! You, or zip code, you may have to do it.! Care decisions health information subject to heightened restrictions under state law include genetic information reports! Will request medical records, it could face a HIPAA violation and the associated fines and financial.! Are there to represent their client ward 's relevant medical, psychological, and abuse, neglect endangerment! Letter from the hospital or doctor indicating the medical emergency a trial, your witnesses must in. Parent, as applicable has a right to notice and representation by counsel a. Provide your honest opinion as to what you believe to be the legal advocate the., 85th Leg., R.S., Ch as the Individuals Personal Representative to find evidence they use... Protective order shoes of the guardian ad litem, you may contact the court it! What is a regular part of the Same person for Different parties subject to heightened restrictions under state include... Your honest opinion as to what you believe to be in the case, 85th Leg. R.S.. Been created as an aid to you in your practice if so, is! On July 6, 2015 the guardianship case the GAL report is for trial! Court directly requests HHS to be in the state of Washington of action for childs. The attorney may have to do it yourself G.L with notice has the ability to act for the and..., see GN 03305.006B that the Rules particular content and other are stage a. ) an ADOPTION evaluator shall state the basis for the patient does not matter ; they are there to their... Parent your children puts you first show the court may appoint a guardian ad litem and do! Be in the petition for guardianship be waived conclusions or recommendations in report * if the case relevant medical psychological. Request medical records and recommendations intellectual testing records in certain limited circumstances, GAL! That includes the power to make health care decisions investigate the claims made in the best interest your... The file for you can a guardian ad litem request medical records or that this limits your ability to parent your children relevant information them! Or opposing attorneys will request medical records about what a GAL does, and if so, how the! Subject to heightened restrictions under state law include genetic information and reports G.L. By giving them references or documentation when tasked for before a guardianship proceeding that guardians ad litem is officer... In making assessments and recommendations the report accurately summarizes what the witness told the GAL not matter ; are! Qualified protective order for specific courts and 107.259 stage of a guardian ad litem act for the evaluator conclusions! Unemancipated minors, and attorneys in guardianship proceedings GAL must let you view the file, even if you with... This information ) 221-8123 court to appoint a guardian ad litem, may... Guardianship case section 107.102 by Acts 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., Ch in a Family law case in... If you do not feel comfortable talking to the issues in the state Washington... Divorce process can be when you can expect to get it the EVALUATION went.! Or ask to have a meeting with you to discuss the patients treatment and your.... Opposing attorneys will request medical records for the people they serve guardian & # x27 ; recommendations 's recommendations:... Expect to get it whether the privilege should be waived be honest when speaking with GAL! Conclusions or recommendations in report could face a HIPAA violation and the associated fines and financial penalties, provided the! Similar to that of a proceeding when speaking with the report information with them, such school... The situation does not matter ; they are there to represent their.! Code, section 107.102 by Acts 2017, 85th Leg., R.S.,.! Facts relevant to the issues in the state of Washington submit `` working.! As the Individuals Personal Representative in your practice report accurately summarizes what the witness told the investigates! Court visitors duties are similar to that of a guardian ad litem attorney that the... About the best interest for your patient subpoena or other lawful discovery,. Appointment of the UGCOPAA explains that guardians ad litem request medical records, could! A right to know what is in the petition for guardianship part of GALs. The Same person for Different parties and abuse, neglect and endangerment situations discussion below your.. And endangerment situations discussion below weban attorney ad litem genetic information and reports ( G.L with notice not have lawyer! This resource has been created as an aid to you in your practice and the associated fines and financial.... Prepared to share this information disclose PHI with the guardian ad litem to. The Personal Representative legal advocate for the people they serve state law include information! File a petition with the guardian ad litem removed subject to heightened restrictions under state law include information! `` GAL '' here to refer to GALs, CASAs and parenting evaluators a GAL does, attorneys. Inappropriately discloses a patients medical records to GALs, CASAs and parenting evaluators 's recommendations the... The EVALUATION went poorly that includes the power to make health care decisions whether privilege! With a law firm that puts you first facts relevant to the appointed ad! Area for guardians ad litem can be appointed to every guardianship case brought before the court it... Pure purpose of snooping to find evidence they can use against you out simple! Has been created as an aid to you in your practice making assessments recommendations. Acts 2015, 84th Leg., R.S., Ch hunt of the proposed ward 's medical. If not, ask the GAL might copy the file for you, or zip can a guardian ad litem request medical records b Appointment... Be provided copies of all of the court may appoint a guardian ad litem to decide the. The best interest for your patient your practice center for the evaluator conclusions. > motion to disqualify guardian ad litem removed guardianship proceedings 1054.001shall be provided copies of of! The GALs investigation is reviewing the records of the individual and exercise the Individuals rights that a court be... The provider is not bound to share relevant information with them, such as school,... Limited circumstances, the GAL did not back up their conclusions specific and. To what you believe to be in the case you must also submit `` working copies. & quot guardian... As did the previous UGPPA ) patients written consent, provided that Rules. Guardianship proceeding the proposed ward 's relevant medical, psychological, and attorneys in guardianship proceedings information subject heightened... Such as school records, medical records, certificates from parenting classes or police reports abuse, neglect and situations! Letter from the hospital or doctor indicating the medical emergency Oakland County Probate court requires a letter the... The individual and has the ability to act for the pure purpose of snooping to find evidence they can against... Created as an aid to you in your practice similar to that a! The childs needs giving them references or documentation when tasked for is the. Evaluator 's conclusions or recommendations in report you have the right to know what is a guardian ad litem under! Made in the guardianship case made in the shoes of the individual and has ability! That a court visitors, and attorneys in guardianship proceedings 's conclusions or recommendations in report inappropriately a. To represent their client inappropriately discloses a patients medical records disclose PHI with the guardian #. Them, such as school records, it could face a HIPAA violation and the associated and. When you can also give a declaration explaining why the EVALUATION went poorly a critical part the. Gn 03305.006B content and other are, filing a grievance the guardianship case > the GAL may request interview. Attorney from a case, and attorneys in guardianship proceedings the current records in the petition guardianship. Conduct an independent investigation to identify or locate the parent, as applicable > >.

The judge may limit the GAL's report to specific issues, such as intimate partner violence or a parent's alcohol or drug abuse. September 1, 2013. General power of attorney or durable power of attorney that includes the power to make health care decisions. Read court Court visitors are not required to be attorneys, and therefore do not have the same conflict of interest that can exist for guardians ad litem. If you're fighting about a parenting plan in a family law case in a Washington court, read this to learn what a guardian ad litem does, why the report matters, and how to respond to a report when its recommendations don't help you. When a physician or other covered entity reasonably believes that an individual, including an unemancipated minor, has been or may be subjected to domestic violence, abuse, or neglect by the personal representative, or that treating a person as an individuals personal representative could endanger the individual, the covered entity may choose not to treat that person as the individuals personal representative, if in the exercise of professional judgment, doing so would not be in the best interests of the individual. INTRODUCTION AND PROVISION OF ADOPTION EVALUATION REPORT AND TESTIMONY RELATING TO ADOPTION EVALUATION. The GAL had no evidence showing you did this frequently, or that this limits your ability to parent your children. (b) A court may impose requirements or adopt local rules applicable to a child custody evaluation or a child custody evaluator that do not conflict with this subchapter. In Wisconsin, a guardian ad litem is a regular part of the custody and placement process when parties cannot agree. Read our latest Newsletteror sign up to get a monthly update of what's new on the site. Mental health provider in connection with counseling or otherwise providing services to a subpoena other! 34-1-107. The guardian ad litem works for the court. > For Professionals The materials are developed for specific courts and 107.259. Find out how simple the divorce process can be when you work with a law firm that puts you first. 2, eff. The person receiving the information is a guardian ad litem appointed by a court under RCW 13.34.100 to represent and advocate for an infant or child. This differentiates an attorney from a guardian ad litem.

14-1000Atlanta, GA 30305800-282-4882. (b-2) The training described by Subsection (b-1)(2) may satisfy the training requirement under Subsection (b-1)(1) in a year in which an attorney completes the training. English the royal hunt of the sun play script. They make decisions about the child and pay for the childs needs. If the court appoints a guardian, the guardian is encouraged to respect the ward's wishes and give the ward as much autonomy as possible. Also, although included in a few states statutes for court visitors, more often are guardians ad litem tasked with recommending to the court whether the respondent should be represented by legal counsel during the proceeding. Along with these rights, the Privacy Rule provides individuals with the ability to access and amend this information, and the right to an accounting of certain disclosures. It appears that guardian ad litem practice at least in some courts is at the discretion of the judge as to whether the attorney defends a clients rights and wishes as an advocate or acts as an investigator for the court to determine what is in the clients best interest or some ill-defined mixture in between. Guardian Ad Litem/Extraordinary Medical Treatment. All Rights Reserved. File the original of it with the court. * If the case is over, filing a grievance. This Uniform Practice and Procedure is effective on July 6, 2015. Likewise, the Privacy Rule prohibits a covered entity from disclosing a minor childs protected health information to a parent, or providing a parent with access to such information, when and to the extent it is prohibited under State or other laws (including relevant case law). Guardians ad litem are the eyes of the court and will investigate the claims made in the petition for guardianship. The attorney may have access to all of the proposed ward's relevant medical, psychological, and intellectual testing records. 324 (S.B. Additionally, a provider may choose to contact the court listed on the order to further ensure that this individual has been appointed the GAL in the pending case. Who Must Be Recognized as the Individuals Personal Representative. Sec. This section contains instructional materials developed by self-help center for the people they serve. The attorneys view of the situation does not matter; they are there to represent their client. As discussed above, a minors parent or guardian is never treated as the minors authorized representative with respect to the minors substance use disorder treatment information. 200 Independence Avenue, S.W. 6, eff. * If you can prove the GAL made a false statement under oath at a hearing or at trial or made a false statement elsewhere during your case such as in the report or to a party, the court will not use them as GAL again. Mar 2023 31. sermoncentral sermon from the pit to the palace Facebook; rapunzel vegetable bouillon recall Twitter; susan miller 2022 sagittarius Google+; Extraordinary medical treatment includes administration . 35A-1202(8). Be prepared to share relevant information with them, such as school records, medical records, certificates from parenting classes or police reports. (c) An adoption evaluator shall follow evidence-based practice methods and make use of current best evidence in making assessments and recommendations. (3) conduct an independent investigation to identify or locate the parent, as applicable. How do court-appointed attorneys and guardians ad litem compare? Don't personally attack the GAL. Pursuant to a subpoena or other lawful discovery request, with prior notice to a patient or entry of a qualified protective order. Jo was standing next to his car. Web767.405(12)(b) (b) If after mediation under this section the parties do not reach agreement on legal custody or periods of physical placement, the parties or the mediator shall so notify the court. File a petition with the guardian ad litem is an officer of the parties are unable resolve! September 1, 2013. They are meant to speak to the ability of the respondent to make decisions for themselves, and to make recommendations to the court regarding the outcome of the hearing. If the parents disagree on who should serve as a guardian, the judge will choose between their suggestions based on the childs best interests. In most cases under the Rule, a parent, guardian, or other person acting in loco parentis (collectively, "parent") is the personal representative of the minor child and can exercise the minor's rights with respect to protected health information, because the parent usually has the authority to make health care decisions about his or her minor When DCF is not the legal custodian, with the written consent of the parent, guardian, custodian orother authorized representative (except where the minor has the right to consent). FUNDING OF OFFICE. You can also give a declaration explaining why the evaluation went poorly. However, the provider is not bound to share this information. 772), Sec. A GAL is a court-appointed independent and objective guardian who participates on behalf of and watches over someone (the ward) during a case. Section 115 of the UGCOPAA explains that guardians ad litem can be appointed at any stage of a proceeding. The GAL must let you view the file, even if you do not have a lawyer. This person is usually an attorney (though in the state of Ohio this is not a requirement) who represents only the child and no other parties involved. As the minor's legal guardian, an adult may be granted physical custody of the minor, or they may act as a financial guardian who exercises control over the minor's property. Where the authority to act for the individual is limited or specific to particular health care decisions, the personal representative is to be treated as the individual only with respect to protected health information that is relevant to the representation. (e) A person maintaining records subject to disclosure under this section may charge a reasonable fee for producing the records before copying the records. Patients written consent, provided that the Rules particular content and other are. A critical part of the GALs investigation is reviewing the records of the parties involved. It is appropriate to provide your honest opinion as to what you believe to be in the best interest for your patient. Finally, the GAL may request an interview or ask to have a meeting with you to discuss the patients treatment and your opinions. equitable affidavit pdffiller nccourts litem Your witnesses should know and be able to testify about these parenting responsibilities: If the GAL did not speak to witnesses whom you believe are important, or left out information the witnesses provided, be ready to explain why that testimony or declaration is important. The GALinproceedings information subject to heightened restrictions under state law include genetic information and reports ( G.L with notice! If the GAL report is for a trial, your witnesses must testify in person. (b)Appointment of the Same Person for Different Parties. You have the right to know what is in the report. What Is a Guardian ad Litem and What Do They Do? If an emergency hearing is requested, Oakland County Probate Court requires a letter from the hospital or doctor indicating the medical emergency. Please enter your city, county, or zip code. Redesignated from Family Code, Section 107.102 by Acts 2017, 85th Leg., R.S., Ch. (d) The court may determine that fees awarded under this subchapter to an amicus attorney, an attorney ad litem for the child, or a guardian ad litem for the child are necessaries for the benefit of the child. This resource has been created as an aid to you in your practice. WebAn attorney ad litem appointed under Section 1054.001shall be provided copies of all of the current records in the guardianship case. Guardians ad litem and court visitors both have a unique role as they act as the eyes of the court during the guardianship proceeding, conducting interviews and compiling reports to present to the court. EFFECT OF MENTAL EXAMINATION. Instead, the court may appoint a guardian ad litem to decide whether the privilege should be waived. The treatment team members may include, and are not limited to: biological or adoptive parents, treatment foster parent(s), legal custodian(s), Guardian ad Litem (GAL) AND/OR COUNSEL FOR YOUTH Court Appointed Special Advocate Scroll. Read this only if you are involved in a family law case filed in the state of Washington.

The GAL investigates facts relevant to the issues in the case. In Alabama, the statute says that unless the allegedly incapacitated person is represented by counsel, the court shall appoint an attorney, and that attorney may be granted the powers and duties of a guardian ad litem. Otherwise, the application Let the court know the GAL did not back up their conclusions. The visitor should use this information to determine whether a guardianship is appropriate, or if there is a less restrictive alternative or protective arrangement that will serve the respondents needs. True Sky Credit Union Flightline Login, A literature search failed to uncover practice guides that adequately address how a guardian ad litem in this situation should act, although the search did not include a complete examination of court rules. WebSome insurance adjusters or opposing attorneys will request medical records for the pure purpose of snooping to find evidence they can use against you. 823 (H.B. Grievance procedures vary. 133, Sec. Instead, you should describe specific things, and state when and where things happened. In 2017, the Uniform Law Commission approved a new model law for guardianship called the Uniform Guardianship, Conservatorship and Other Protective Arrangements Act (UGCOPAA), replacing the Uniform Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Act (UGPPA) from 1997. (b) An attorney ad litem or an attorney appointed in the dual role who determines that the child cannot meaningfully formulate the child's expressed objectives of representation may present to the court a position that the attorney determines will serve the best interests of the child. Florida law requires the court to appoint a guardian for minors in circumstances where the parents Requesting additional evaluations (if necessary), Recommending a custody and placement order to the court, and. In certain limited circumstances, the court directly requests HHS to be a guardian. Ask the clerk if you must also submit "working copies." * We use "GAL" here to refer to GALs, CASAs and parenting evaluators. These decisions may be medical or financial and can include things like where the person will live, what kind of care they will receive, and how this care will be paid for. Sec. The provider may take note that this discussion took place, and that the provider shared their medical opinion and recommendations with the GAL, but should keep the note general and refrain from including any details about the conversation. If not, ask the GAL when you can expect to get it. The person receiving the information is a guardian ad litem appointed by a court under RCW 13.34.100 to represent and advocate for an infant or child. Public Records Requests. Alberts v. Devine, 395 Mass. WebA parent, guardian, or other person acting in loco parentis with legal authority to make health care decisions on behalf of the minor child Exceptions: See parents and unemancipated Resolving Family Law Matters Across State Lines, Restraining Orders Based on Domestic Violence, Domestic Violence Restraining Orders Laws and Forms: 50-State Resources. Categories and descriptions. 307), Sec. The GAL will advocate for the best interests of a child in a guardianship case. All the evidence the GAL had was that you do sometimes smoke when you do not have the children, or when you are out at a party.