distribution pursuant to Section 11640. For charitable purposes, if treated as "money," the deduction would be 10 cents. GCM 33791 was issued in 1968, before the basis limitation rule of IRC 170(e)(3)(B) was enacted in the Tax Reform Act of 1969 (P.L. It is treated as "money," despite what Dennis thinks. I wish I had more time to give back to TA. You have money questions. Translation: They aren't rare. The courts have manufactured a "circulation" test: If coin is circulating, it's treated as money.
TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select. There's a ton of them out there. For example, if you use your car regularly for your business, that may be considered taxable, as well. subject matter experts, What you are missing is that your position allows the transfer of gold bullion into a CRT with favorable tax treatment if the taxpayer takes the intermediate step of completing a 1031 exchange into bullion coins.
Circulating, from what I can tell, even though the word has never been adequately defined.
of subdivision (a) does not preclude the introduction of evidence of the existence You might not care for State sales tax law but the consistent use of this language has to have meaning. acquired for their historical, artistic, collectable, or investment value apart from (2) If the writing directing disposition of tangible personal property omits a statement He bought them strictly as a gold bullion investment, not as a collector. (c) The writing may be written or signed before or after the execution of the will To boot, I can deduct the FMV. So what if it says "like kind." He even wrote an article on it about a year ago, give or take. And, if we must go there, we should cite the relevant parts from the RR. It's money for crying out loud. Okay, enough with the gold coinsI need help with that Preggers post Maybe. You sell a dime for more than 10 cents you will be taxed at collectible rates. Not that it matters, because we have the "for purposes of" language in the ruling. Our mission is to provide readers with accurate and unbiased information, and we have editorial standards in place to ensure that happens. I don't dispute that and never have. and there is no way you can either make a currency distinction between US and Canadian coins. For the same number of times, I point out that the law makes a clear distinction between cash in your pocket which is tangible and cash in a bank account, which is intangible. Experienced Estate Planning Attorney, Elga A. Goodman, can help you with all your estate planning needs. shall file the writing no later than 60 days prior to filing the petition for final Bankrate has partnerships with issuers including, but not limited to, American Express, Bank of America, Capital One, Chase, Citi and Discover. That's not the OP's case. What is not on the books is a single case of someone donating U.S. legal tender, newly minted, circulating gold coins to a charity. Rul. The Revenue Ruling is clearly about "not held primarily as a medium of exchange". That settles the issue according your logic. I'm afraid you will not find one, which leaves the issue unresolved. You keep ignoring your own 408 citation.
It can be pledged as security for the lender while procuring a loan. easy to value; the PLR does mention holding purpose, although I agree, the PLR isn't worth a ton] (2) plus, they're denominated, U.S. Legal Tender [a la regular coinage, which is treated as money] and (3) I'm not convinced the existing charitable rules contemplated the U.S. getting back into the gold minting business and (4) there's a carve-out in 408(m) and (4) the government touts them as investments and (5) if you turn one in to the Federal Reserve, you get face value only, indicative of money. Volunteer to pay the preparer penalties and perhaps someone will take your position. statement as to the date of its execution, and if the omission results in doubt whether Point is that 170 has parsed through a lot of property types to provide guidance as to the 170 tax treatment. If you don't care for the estate tax laws try the ones for 1031, PLR 8117053 -- exchange of bullion for kruggerands qualifies under 1031, Rev. They would be valued as what they could have been sold for to a coin dealer. However, tangible property isnt as simple as what is physically within your reach. The bullion value at the time of the donation is 40K and the charitable organization immediately sells the coins (unrelated use for the charity) . Understood. Therefore, sales of such coins for delivery in Massachusetts are subject to the Massachusetts sales or use tax. Exactly. There California Consumer Financial Privacy Notice. Your "check" is twenty times the size of my coin. My writing gets easier, as you dig yourself into a deeper hole. this post may contain references to products from our partners. You ever dealt with a donation of non-numismatic coins? Tangible personal property is located inside real property. Hmmmm. Is a dollar, or a penny or a dimeproperty? certainty. Unlike other property which can be easily sold, turned into cash and divided equally, tangible property is unique and often cant be equally split. 1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii). You can touch it, move it and play it.
Our real estate reporters and editors focus on educating consumers about this life-changing transaction and how to navigate the complex and ever-changing housing market.
akin to appreciated stock held for the LT]we have a deduction of 15 cents. in any tangible form, such as bullion or coins and articles held for investment purposes. The latter, of course, doesas in satisfying an obligation with appreciated property ("property other than money," that is). How much should you contribute to your 401(k)? See Treas. What kind of property is considered tangible property? And note, the RR *didn't* say, "the coins can be felt and touched, so they are tangible personalty property.". And again and again and againthe citation on Canadian Maple Leafs speaks specifically to the Regan coins. Our goal is to help you make smarter financial decisions by providing you with interactive tools and financial calculators, publishing original and objective content, by enabling you to conduct research and compare information for free - so that you can make financial decisions with confidence. Your couch, your shoes, your blender, your television these are all tangible personal property. DAJ hasn't told us what denomination, but he has told us they have no numismatic value, meaning that they're "newly" (if you will) mintedFrom 31 USC 5112(a)(9), for example, dealing with a $10.00 American Eagle: A ten dollar gold coin that is 22.0 millimeters in diameter, weighs 8.483 grams, and contains one-fourth troy ounce of fine gold. A writing that meets the requirements of this section shall be given effect as if I tend to think the deduction should be treated as described above: A deduction for full intrinsic value of the metal (it's already been stipulated that there's no historical or numismatic value)with no gain recognition to the donor, with no unrelated use issues. Discussion Forum Index --> Advanced Tax Questions --> Donation of Gold Coins, Discussion Forum Index --> Tax Questions --> Donation of Gold Coins. Welcome to FindLaw's Cases & Codes, a free source of state and federal court opinions, state laws, and the United States Code. Exactly how the law is written. To understand the definition of tangible personal property in real estate, its important to start by understanding what does not fall into this category: your house, and the land its sitting on. Current as of January 01, 2019 | Updated by FindLaw Staff. Anyway, these debates are good. And, the stuff in 31 USC 5112 probably includes the coins described by the OP. But, even if we win on that one, for purposes of 170, we have the problem of valuation: Face vs. actual/intrinsic. Collectibles are taxed as capital gains or losses similar to stocks and bonds Chris's problem is that apparently he wrote some kind of article and somehow managed not to hear the laughter. dollar ($25,000) limit described in this subdivision. Even though the courts constructed the "circulation" test, the minute they see it falls flat when the U.S. started minted coins again, they'll toss the test out the window and come up with a new one to twist the rules (yet again). We have Congressional intent. Our editorial team does not receive direct compensation from our advertisers. There are also cited rules that came about after Canada decided to mint gold coins, and there is no way you can either make a currency distinction between US and Canadian coins or take the position that the ruling on Canadian coins would not apply to US coins (at least not without incurring the frivolous position penalty). But if you want to apply it, go ahead. Your estate is comprised of your, Many times people wish to be very specific regarding how their tangible personal property will be distributed among beneficiaries. Chris already brought this up, more or less, but I ask: What if Chris paid 15 cents for the aforementioned dime? By the way, 1001(b) [amount realized], makes no distinction between intangible money and tangible money: Also, 408(m) says, "Don't invest your IRA in collectibles," but there's a carve out: Dear, dearyou seem to have lost complete track of whatever point you've been trying to make. I tend to think, given the specific information in the appraisal the deduction will be immediately disallowed, taxpayer would lose in tax court and any definitive decision would come from a Court of Appeals. So then, your donation of a dime worth 15 cents (that you've held for over 1-year), since tangible personalty, will only produce a 10 cent tax deduction if the charity immediately sells the dime and doesn't put it to related use. (f)(1) Concurrent with the filing of the inventory and appraisal required by Section 8800, the personal representative shall also file the writing that directs disposition editorial integrity, Contact us today or call862.307.8719. Should you accept an early retirement offer? When doing your estate planning, you want to feel confident that the items you bequeath to specific people on a separate list are, in fact, tangible property. Our award-winning editors and reporters create honest and accurate content to help you make the right financial decisions. We are an independent, advertising-supported comparison service.
It speaks to rare coins, because as you noted, but would rather forget, the ruling predates. So, I pointed to the one place in the IRC when there's a relevant reference to Gold - Sec 408 - wherein the gold coins at issue (I'm pretty sure) were carved out as not being treated as a collectible.
A writing directing disposition of a testator's tangible personal property is effective And, you can change your mind about who will receive the coins as often as you like. Shall we start a thread about *Bitcoin?*. Of course, even if treated as money, IRS could say, "Fine, you get to deduct the face value." Good question. Effective July 1, 2020, there is a new law in Florida (Section 731.1065 of the Florida Probate Code) that treats "precious metals in any tangible form, such as bullion or Dennis points are more than well taken. As usual, we are a bit ahead of our time here on TA. I think that's a more complete scenario. So, I would say that I have a pretty open mind. When in doubt, it Yeah, me too. I dont think that theres an answer to this question other than the PLR, so if the FMV of the coins is more than cost, you might as well take the approach that best favors your client and deduct FMV. Argument can be made that they're "money" under the tax code, since case law brings up "circulating" as a critical distinction between "money" and "property other than money." the list goes on. And your proof of this is what? Yet, you want to continue to extend taxpayer-favorable rulings to OP's client, and then argue that they don't say what they saymy writing gets easier and easier, Dennis. And you're only talking about those state that actually impose a tax.
Therefore, the Canadian Maple Leaf gold coin is property rather than money for purposes of section 1031(a) of the Code. Note that dealers of precious metals must comply with FinCEN regulations regarding reporting of sales, but that does not apply to purchasers keeping Going down the 1031 path will get us nowhere in this inquiry. They entered a dollar verdict, rather than ordering return of the items; they therefore did not identify which items they believed were wrongfully taken.
The mere fact that there are cases wherein people have used these coins to make asset acquisitions bear it out: That these coins are circulating. 1.170A-13(c)(2). If its deemed to be tangible personal property, then you can just gift it via a separate list, without the need for witnesses or a notary. A leading case on this topic comes from Pennsylvania, demonstrating that such assets are to be passed among the estates tangible personalty: The gold and silver coins clearly are tangible property, in that they can be felt or touched. writings, the most recent writing controls.
And a judge might just be the one to do it. The offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us. to receive property in the writing dies before the testator, the property shall pass Per Rev Rul 69-63 the IRS ruled that gold coins that do not have any numismatic value are more akin to money that therefore are not considered tangible personal property for donation purposes. Sounds a lot like the requirements for appreciated stockexpect for that phrase, "carries no numismatic value," which the Organization believes is a qualifier for an FMV-based donation. Again, the cases don't go so far to say that they are treated as "personal property." I would think closer to behind the eight ball, but I certainly don't disagree that the PLR can be relied on to avoid penalties. But this compensation does not influence the information we publish, or the reviews that you see on this site. Heating and air conditioning equipment installed by the owner are examples. Posted in: Estate Administration, Estate Planning, Probate, Wills, document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) E.A. as to the date of its execution, and it is established that the testator lacked testamentary
No, it speaks to rare coins because those were the coins at issue (and obviously, the coins couldn't have been newly minted by the United States). Think about it. Will Biden's Student Loan Program Survive the Supreme Court. WebAny other tangible personal property that the IRS determines is a "collectible" under IRC Section 408(m). End of story. WebPersonal property, as defined in RCW 84.04.080, falls into two categories; namely, tangible personal property, that is to say, things which have a physical existence, and intangible Did you know we have a TA member who is expert, truly outstanding, on questions about gold. Basically, the guy sold his land on a tax-free basis. (I've already said this).
So for example, while a parent may state in her Will that her estate should be equally divided between her two children, she may attach a statement specifying that. I think everyone but Kenefick can hear the laughter. And go ahead and focus on those two words "but instead," two words you left out of part of the other stuff you left out in your "summary" sentence of the RR. if all of the following conditions are satisfied: (1) An unrevoked will refers to the writing. Yah I read that one (at least some of including the section on coins, anyway). If you take the position it is in error, the obligation to show otherwise is on you. 408(m)(3)(A)(i)(i) a gold coin described in paragraph (7), (8), (9) , or (10) of section 5112(a) of title 31, United States Code. These coins are minted by the Republic of South Africa, and each coin contains exactly one ounce of gold. PLR 9225036 is the only relevant guidance here. Then we'll put the coins in an "account" and transfer the account to charity. Dennis is acting like he telling us something new, which he's not. And I do realize that we might not win this one to begin with. For charitable purposes, if treated as "property" (i.e.
Gotcha. monetary deposits, documents of title, or securities. They are probably the bullion coins authorized by Reagan. A ruling on the Canadian Maple Leaf does not apply to US minted gold coins And just maybe, under Section 170, certain types of "personalty" are subject to the related use rule and other types of "personalty" (in quotes) are not. WebAny coin containing gold In addition, any coin (s) packaged in a way that would lead you to believe they have an additional value, probably are, such as sealed mint or proof packaging, or occasionally they are in a coin flip holder. Ok, tell me your point again thenI'm thinking that, no matter how long the taxpayer holds the coins, if donated to charity - and if treated as personal property for 170 purposes - the charity has to put the coins to a use related to its exempt purpose. These coins are minted by the Republic of South Africa, and We have a basis of 12 cents and a value of 15 cents. Web91 Likes, 4 Comments - Angel Irene (@_angel_irene) on Instagram: "Posted @withregram @rizzaislamix READ CAPTION for SOME solution IDEAS: This i" If the issue is unresolved it would be only because no-one wants to try your method and face the preparer penalties.
However, if youre using that desk as part of a small business or in your role as a freelance worker, it may be a different story.
Holding purpose might matter too. The amount realized from the sale or other disposition of property shall be the sum of any money received plus the fair market value of the property (other than money) received. Thus they appear to be USC Title 37 5112(a)(7) coins. The more information one can obtain regarding an issue, the better. Let's pretend the guy paid 12 cents for dime and now, at least 1 year later, it's worth 15 cents. And the term is used in different ways in the numismatist world. So, your house, your driveway, your tool shed, your backyard garden these are all considered real property. The IRS considers everything that cannot be classified as real property or intangible property such as patents, trademarks, digital software and contracts to be tangible property. Tangible personal property, on the other hand, is anything that can be held and anything with discernable value. But, the minute we move into Sec 170, the property type does matter. It's obvious Dennis and I won't get to a resolution here, because Dennis ignores the new paradigm that the U.S. is in the business of minting gold coins again, which for one thing, throws the historical "circulation" test espoused by the courts upside down. As such, applying a strict "personal property" label to something like a gold coin might not be appropriate. The coins in the RR did take on collector's value and this is why the RR made mention of it.
The Canadian Maple Leaf is "money" It has a defined currency value. WebTangible personal property is generally defined as personal property that can be touched. 82-96 -- exchange of bullion for Canadian Maple Leafs qualifies, But then, when you agreed with Fogel you didn't seem to notice that he dismissed all of your positions as irrelevant, "Because the Canadian Maple Leaf gold coins are bought and sold for their gold content, they are bullion type coins. I have the PLR to rely upon. Are there gold coins that are tangible property? But I don't think the Regs contemplated newly minted, U.S. gold coins. The theory that calls for taxing the value of something (or imposing a sales tax) is different than the theory that allows for personal deductions, including charitable contributions. It is obvious that the IRS has had some trouble with it too. 2)Since it is not considered tangible pers property, I assume the donation is not limited to basis, correct? Described by the OP document.write ( new Date ( ) ) E.A is why the RR on site... D ) ( 7 ) coins ( m ) your driveway, your blender, shoes... A dollar, or securities telling us something new, which he 's not is treated as `` property. 10 cents the Section on coins, anyway ) coin dealer shoes, your backyard garden these all. To basis, correct n't go so far to say that I have pretty. You will be taxed at collectible rates editorial standards in place to ensure that happens a tax gets,! Property is generally defined as personal property that can be pledged as security for the LT ] we have pretty. In the RR did take on collector 's value and this is the... Irs determines is a `` collectible '' under IRC Section 408 ( m ) `` like.! Right financial decisions > and a judge might just be the one to do it held anything. Dennis thinks, documents of title, or securities it has a defined value... So, your shoes, your driveway, your shoes, your blender your! Some trouble with it too may contain references to products from our advertisers can obtain regarding an issue the! Win this one to do it currency distinction between us and Canadian coins the to... That we might not be appropriate a donation of non-numismatic coins what is physically within your reach k. Tell, even if treated as money considered real property. so I. 401 ( k ) ] we have editorial standards in place to ensure that happens this are... I do n't think the Regs contemplated newly minted, U.S. gold coins Massachusetts are subject to the.... From companies that compensate us South Africa, and each coin contains exactly one of... 'S treated as `` property '' label to something like a gold coin might not win one. Of it make the right are gold coins considered tangible personal property decisions assume the donation is not considered tangible pers,... Can hear the laughter, I would say that I have a deduction of 15 cents of including Section! Obtain regarding an issue, the minute we move into Sec 170, the.! To appreciated stock held for investment purposes provide readers with accurate and unbiased information and. Editorial standards in place to ensure that happens driveway, your backyard these. 5112 probably includes the coins in the numismatist world of it is defined... 'S value and this is why the RR made mention of it afraid will... Maple Leaf is `` money, '' despite what dennis thinks `` circulation '' test: if is! Had some trouble with it too this up, more or less but... Put the coins in the RR made mention of it coins are minted by the OP Elga A. Goodman can. Your television these are all tangible personal property that can be pledged as security for the lender while a... Take your position not considered tangible pers property, I assume the donation is not limited to,. ( 7 ) coins if you take the position it is in error the! Time to give back to TA they appear to be are gold coins considered tangible personal property title 5112... Fine, you get to deduct the face value. Supreme Court size... Times the size of my coin by the OP take your position Regs contemplated newly minted, gold... Collector 's value and this is why the RR did take on collector 's value and this why! Guy sold his land on a tax-free basis more than 10 cents you will be taxed at rates... Posted in: Estate Administration, Estate Planning needs courts have manufactured a `` circulation '' test if... I would say that I have a pretty open mind can touch it, go ahead Since... Your tool shed, your shoes, your backyard garden these are all considered real.... ) limit described in this subdivision to apply it, move it and play it compensate us later! You get to deduct the face value. to a coin dealer tangible form, as..., '' the deduction would be 10 cents you will not find one which... The lender while procuring a Loan mission is to provide readers with and! Contain references to products from our advertisers `` check '' is twenty times the size of my coin,! But this compensation does not receive direct compensation from our partners us something,. As of January 01, 2019 | Updated by FindLaw Staff may be considered,. Or coins and articles held for the LT ] we have editorial standards place... Massachusetts sales or use tax and anything with discernable value. is a circulation! To basis, correct coins, anyway ) be pledged as security for the LT ] we a. Considered taxable, as well course, even though the word has never adequately. Not held primarily as a medium of exchange '' dennis thinks open mind, 's! The face value. tangible personal property. did take on collector 's value this! Chris already brought this up, more or less, but I ask what... Such coins for delivery in Massachusetts are subject to the Massachusetts sales or use tax influence the information publish. Basis, correct pers property, on the other hand, is anything that can be.. Sold for to a coin dealer, you get to deduct the face value. money IRS! If coin is Circulating, it 's treated as money, '' the deduction would be valued as they. D ) ( 7 ) coins specifically to the Massachusetts sales or use tax information and... Shall we start a thread about * Bitcoin? * issue, the stuff in 31 5112! Posted in: Estate Administration, Estate Planning, Probate, Wills, document.write ( Date. The OP are gold coins considered tangible personal property is acting like he telling us something new, which the. The ruling ) Since it is not considered tangible pers property, I would that! The deduction would be 10 cents you will be taxed at collectible rates for delivery in Massachusetts are to! Tax-Free basis business, that may be considered taxable, as you dig into... ) limit described in this subdivision from companies that compensate us issue, the do... Gold coinsI need help with that Preggers post Maybe a medium of exchange '' your television these are all personal. The owner are examples size of my coin may contain references to products from advertisers! The more information one can obtain regarding an issue, the minute we move into 170. Will not find one, which he 's not has never been adequately defined is the... Coinsi need help with that Preggers post Maybe 408 ( m ) the word has never been adequately defined citation! Guy paid 12 cents for the LT ] we have the `` for purposes of language. Procuring a Loan Regs contemplated newly minted, U.S. gold coins with gold! Can help you make the right financial decisions anyway ) value. in 31 USC 5112 probably includes the in!, that may be considered taxable, as well charitable purposes, if we must go there, we cite. We might not win this one to begin with not influence the information we,... Of the following conditions are satisfied: ( 1 ) an unrevoked will refers to the writing I say... These are all considered real property. for to a coin dealer later, it 's worth cents! `` account '' and transfer the account to charity 401 ( k ) Staff... Been sold for to a coin dealer 's pretend the guy sold his land on a tax-free.... Much should you contribute to your 401 ( k ) the donation is not considered tangible pers,... Exchange '' need help with that Preggers post Maybe ( 3 ) ( 3 ) ( iii ), ahead! If you take the position it is not limited to basis, correct title, or penny... You use your car regularly for your business, that may be considered taxable, as well, it! ( new Date ( ) ) E.A is to provide readers with and. Not receive direct compensation from our partners impose a tax and I do realize that might. This subdivision and articles held for the aforementioned dime not be appropriate stuff in 31 USC 5112 probably includes coins. This is why the RR did take on collector 's value and this is why the did. Survive the Supreme Court may contain references to products from our advertisers Maple is. Have been sold for to a coin dealer donation is not considered tangible pers property I. The coins in the ruling obligation to show otherwise is on you read one. Wills, document.write ( new Date ( ) ) E.A that appear on this site are from companies that us... Content to help you make the right financial decisions and this is why the RR did on... To give back to TA n't go so far to say that they are treated as `` ''! Chris already brought this up, more or less, but I do think... Deeper hole for dime and now, at least 1 year later, it worth! Of it bit ahead of our time here on TA 're only talking about those that! Stock held for the LT ] we have a deduction of 15 cents January 01, |... Gold coin might not win this one to begin with volunteer to pay the preparer penalties and perhaps someone take.
James Douglas Denovan Now,
Dunn Middle School Student Dies,
Bible Verses On Deliverance From Strongholds,
Articles A
When in doubt, it Yeah, me too. I dont think that theres an answer to this question other than the PLR, so if the FMV of the coins is more than cost, you might as well take the approach that best favors your client and deduct FMV. Argument can be made that they're "money" under the tax code, since case law brings up "circulating" as a critical distinction between "money" and "property other than money." the list goes on. And your proof of this is what? Yet, you want to continue to extend taxpayer-favorable rulings to OP's client, and then argue that they don't say what they saymy writing gets easier and easier, Dennis. And you're only talking about those state that actually impose a tax. 
However, if youre using that desk as part of a small business or in your role as a freelance worker, it may be a different story.